Located along the Golden Mile, Mountain View Diner is one of those classic throwback spots that never tries too hard — because it doesn’t have to. The red vinyl booths, chrome accents, and nostalgic diner buzz set the tone before you even sit down. But if there’s one thing this place takes seriously, it’s dessert. Everything is baked in-house, with two bakers splitting the workload daily, and that dedication shows up the moment a slice hits your table.

This visit was a rerate of a cheesecake I reviewed years ago — originally an 8/10 — but this time, I ordered their seasonal Pumpkin Cheesecake. And let me just say: this slice didn’t just improve… it ascended.

When it arrives, it’s clear Mountain View Diner isn’t in the business of modest portions. This slice is massive, taking center stage on a simple white plate. No drizzle. No garnish. No theatrics. And honestly? None needed. This cheesecake knows exactly what it brings to the table.

The marbled top and layered pumpkin swirl make it visually striking before you even dig in. But the real magic reveals itself on that first bite:
rich pumpkin flavor,
beautifully spiced,
dense yet irresistibly creamy,
and just sweet enough without overdoing it.

It’s everything you want fall to taste like.

The filling showcases the skill of their bakers — expertly balanced, smooth, and packed with warm seasonal flavor. The pumpkin is bold but not overpowering, and the cream cheese base still shines through. It’s a genuinely impressive combination that keeps you wanting another forkful.

The only note I had — and it’s a small one — is that the crust could’ve been thicker. With a slice this large, it deserves a sturdier, more substantial foundation. The flavor was there, but a bit more structure would have perfectly grounded the weight of this absolute unit of a cheesecake.

At $10.45, it’s priced fairly for the portion, quality, and the fact that it’s baked fresh in-house. This was an easy call to raise the original 8/10 to a well-earned 9/10.

Verdict:

A powerhouse fall cheesecake with bold pumpkin flavor, a creamy, dreamy texture, and that old-school diner confidence that doesn’t need decorations to impress. A must-try seasonal slice that truly delivers.

Flavor – Pumpkin Cheesecake
Price – $10.45
Rating – 9/10

If you would like to try it for yourself, the location is below: